Step 1: Start with the Why
As with any goal, starting with the Why is the necessary first step. Defining the objectives of the overall audit program, the key compliance areas to be covered and the Key Performance Indicator (KPI) criteria will help operations managers design a better audit plan.
- Do you want to track compliance with brand standards?
- Do you want to track the customer service over different stores?
- Do you want to check on the hygiene standards of your outlets?
- Do you want to check the completion of operational processes?
- Are your outlets following merchandising guidelines?
Whatever your audit needs may be, the objectives of the audit need to be clearly defined to reap the benefits of an operations audit.
Step 2: Identify the Areas of Audit
Once the goals are set you need to identify all the Key Performance Indicator (KPI) areas that need to be audited and group them into the key compliance areas to be covered. If you want to audit brand compliance across all stores, you need to identify all areas that may affect how the brand is perceived. For example:
- In-Store Corporate Identity
- Staff Appearance
- Customer Experience
- Handling Customer Complaints
Step 3: Identify who conducts the audit
Generally, we have people in 3 roles that involved in conducting audits
- Field Team Auditor: company Store Managers or Area Managers
- Dedicated Internal Quality Assurance Auditor: company personnel whose only job is to conduct audits
- External Auditor: 3rd Party Auditor engaged to conduct audits
Using an internal Field Team is the most cost-effective way to conduct audits. The disadvantage of using an internal field team is that there are certain conflicts of interest in the scoring of the audits. Having a dedicated quality assurance team to conduct audits may provide for more unbiased scoring of the audits; however as this option requires a separate team dedicated to implementing and maintaining audits, it is a resource-heavy solution that works better for larger companies.
Using a 3rd Party Auditor may be a good solution to help reduce both conflicts of interests that may arise by using internal field teams and avoid the high costs incurred in maintaining a dedicated quality assurance team. Since external auditors are not tied to the operating metrics of the audited stores, the audit scores are much less likely to carry bias and provide a more accurate assessment of ground situations. These 3rd Party Auditors are paid by the audits they conduct.
Astreem Consulting provides 3rd Party Auditor services to help you conduct audits. The experienced team at Astreem designs practical audit programs that are targeted at key performance areas and conducts operational & brand audits for F&B, Education & Retail businesses.
Step 4: Designing the Audit Questions
The designing of audit questions depend on several factors:
- Who is conducting the audit: If the field team member is conducting the audit, you want to keep the audit simple and short.
- Type of questions asked: The audit questions should also be from the view of recording a fact (objective) rather than asking for opinion (subjective). Statements with a Yes/no answer or those with a graded range are the most commonly used audit question formats.
- Frequency of the audit: Designing the audit is closely related to the frequency of the audit. If you are going to visit the store every day, then the audit can be short and you can vary the sections covered. But if the frequency is once a quarter, designing a more comprehensive audit to cover the various aspects of an operational audit would be preferable.
Step 5: Conducting the Audit
Before rolling out your audit program, you need to decide which tools will be used to conduct the audit. Excel spreadsheets or physical hard copies are commonly used for Audits; the problem occurs in collation and interpretation of the data. Copious man-hours are often invested to clean, analyse and archive the collected data. Another issue occurs when you need to collate reports from past period records to make performance comparisons across periods – this is also time-intensive for personnel, especially non-dedicated auditors with other responsibilities. This can be resolved by using smart online audit tools likeTree AMS (Automated Management System). The system helps you to seamlessly collate data, run different reports between periods and see performance across compliance areas. You reduce a lot of time in data collation and data storage.
Step 6: Analysing the Results
The whole point of the audit system is to give you insights about the performance across various key compliance areas of your business. Analysing the results and incorporating the insights as feedback into operations decisions is key to performance improvement of your brand.
For example, if specific outlets are consistently showing poor audit scores in the Customer Service Audit, then specific action at the store level must be taken. The way staff are trained to handle customers must be addressed. A retraining session may be scheduled for the staff, followed up by a post-training audit to check that Customer Service performance has improved as indicated by better audit results.
Step 7: Improving the Audit Program
The last important step is to make sure that the audit program stays relevant to the management goals of your brand and business. Regular reviews are essential to improving the quality and maintaining the relevance of the audit program.
To conclude, a well-designed audit program is about providing insights, feedback and enforcing accountability throughout the organisation. It is one of the best ways of improving and sustaining the performance of your brand.
Need a more tailored approach?
Speak to our team about our full suite of capabilities and develop a bespoke project.